Studies find that electrical stimulation to one side of the brain helps improve depression
About 15 years ago, researchers first began using transcranial magnetic stimulation to combat depression. The treatment involves placing a specially-designed coil next to a patient’s head. When a weak electrical current is run through the coil, it induces an electrical current in the brain tissue underneath. Early reports suggested that after a few weeks of daily rounds of the regimen, some depressed patients began to feel better.
But even after a new treatment becomes generally accepted, much tinkering has to be done to work out how to get the best results. Some studies, for instance, have found that low-frequency stimulation − about 1 Hz − to regions on the brain’s right side worked well. Others found that adding to that some high frequency stimulation − about 10 Hz − on the left side was effective. There were also reasons to think that low frequency stimulation to both brain hemispheres might work.
Jeff Daskalakis, who heads the Brain Stimulation Treatment and Research Unit at the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health and is a U of T professor of psychiatry, wanted to compare these paradigms head to head. He and his colleagues studied 219 patients suffering from treatment-resistant depression and randomly assigned them to one of the three treatment groups.
The researchers’ hypothesis was that bilateral stimulation would work better than unilateral. After four weeks of daily treatments, over 50 per cent of all the patients had shown improvement. But not only was there was no advantage of bilateral over unilateral treatment, there were hints that unilateral was in fact better. They published their results in the latest issue of Psychological Medicine.
The antidepressant effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation may not have much to do with frequency or laterality, they concede in the paper. It could be that repetitively stimulating the front part of the brain at any frequency somehow strengthens connections, leading to a healthier brain function and, in turn, an improved mood.